Updated June 2026
An independent Sarasota agency serving the Gulf Coast since 2016.
Camelot Insurance Company is an independent property and casualty insurance agency headquartered in Sarasota, Florida, serving the Gulf Coast since 2016.
We work for our clients, not for any single carrier. When we quote your business or your home, we match the risk to the markets that fit it across admitted carriers, surplus-lines markets, and specialty wholesale relationships.
What we do
Our core practice is commercial insurance for Sarasota-area businesses — from main-street retailers, restaurants, contractors, and professional offices to coastal property, habitational, and hard-to-place accounts that need specialty market access.
Alongside the business, we handle the owner’s personal coverage: home, auto, umbrella, flood, watercraft, and collections. Many clients eventually keep both sides with us because one advisor who sees the whole picture can catch gaps that separate agents miss.
How we work
We are deliberately a small office with a concierge model. You deal with a licensed advisor, not a call center, and we are direct about fit. If a risk belongs in a different market than ours, we will say so. If a renewal is going to be difficult, you will hear it from us early, with options, not at the deadline.
Our quoting process is designed to be fast, but every placement decision is reviewed by a human who understands Florida coastal underwriting and local business realities.
Who’s behind it
Camelot is led by Hayden Dudley, a Florida-licensed insurance agent. Hayden’s Florida personal license number is W004920.
Camelot Insurance Company’s Florida agency license number is L097598.
Licensing
Camelot Insurance Company is a Florida-licensed insurance agency. Verify any Florida agent or agency license through the Florida Department of Financial Services license search.
Despite the word “Company” in our legal name, Camelot is an independent insurance agency — we represent clients to carriers; we are not the carrier.
5343 Paylor Lane, Suite 200, Sarasota, FL 34240 · (941) 217-7418